Elektrine lite

← Feed

@LyallMorrison@cloudisland.nz

2026-11-04 12:47 UTC

@xgranade@wandering.shop The first thing I'm reaching for is the paradox of tolerance. We exist in a society, which is messy and uncomfortable at times. We tolerate things we don't necessarily agree with, and generally see tolerance as a virtue. However, there's a line. Tolerating those who don't tolerate back is a vulnerable position. One answer to the paradox of tolerance is to view it as a social contract, and the intolerant party is breaking the contract and making themselves an enemy, removing our obligation to tolerate their bullshit. We're familiar with software pushing unwelcome updates. Often it's well-intentioned change or mildly predatory capitalist friction which we tend to tolerate. The intent behind the change means a lot. Releasing a bug or a security vulnerability is measurably bad, but also easy to forgive and mostly a matter of competence and reliability. The social contract is intact. Releasing version 14.88 for some reason, is a breach of the social contract. 1/2

Replies (1)

  • @xgranade@wandering.shop Coming back to AI stuff, we're in a difficult position where some groups are making well-meaning but maybe misguided attempts to provide AI features or ship faster by using AI themselves. Others are harvesting knowledge, maybe wothout using AI directly, or selling out to fascist oligarchs. The meaningful dividing line isn't a technical measurement between virtuous traditional projects we should tolerate and evil projects with AI cooties we must reject, because the wrong people can end up on either side. But that doesn't mean we should give up - our colleagues who are still part of our social contract can be convinced to behave better through social pressure, and we should find our community lines around code quality and provenance. Those who reject the social contract of mutual tolerance - say, ignoring policies against AI contribution - aren't choosing to be part of the conversation and we'll have to treat them as spam. 2/2, dashed off at 2am, please interpret kindly

    Open ##5479523