Elektrine lite

← Feed

@chrisg@kolektiva.social

2026-10-24 14:04 UTC

When I argue against the use of AI products with the teams I work with, one argument I often have to counter is that "of course AI is problematic, but so is using fossil fuels either directly (car fuel) or indirectly (electricity)". But these two are not equivalent, for two reasons. First - obviously there is no ethical consumption under capitalism. Anything we use, any resource dependent on a network of extraction is tainted by exploitation and colonialism. However, arguing from a position of purity frames any possible action as either going all in as a hermit or fully embracing the status quo. That's equivalent to passively accepting the current state of affairs without nuance or introspection. That's not an argument or a political position. It's conceding defeat. Second - AI is not the same as fossil fuels. There is no need to use AI products. Having to use electricity to cook your food is not the same as using AI to do work. You cannot (reasonably) opt out of the former, but you definitely don't have to do the latter. I understand that it may seem _convenient_, but that's the choice you're making then, isn't it? Effectively, in this time, with the technofascist project at full swing, you choose convenience over not participating in the AI cult's agenda. That's your choice. I think I have actually convinced people with this reasoning, at least well enough to stop them from bringing up this line of argument any more. It worked much better than focusing on the effects of AI use, I think because it requires people to rethink their agency when engaging with these products.

Replies (0)

No replies.